rvt and penyours have different dissections of the scene where Ben sees his mom -

rvt: http://www.losttv-forum.com/forum/showpost.php?p=1528098&postcount=529

penyours: http://www.thefuselage.com/Threaded/showpost.php?p=1547363&postcount=1648

Ooh cool. But their versions are like completely different though.

These ones are interesting:
help us come through the fence (13.7)
and we're sending one, don't argue

Although I notice Penyours doesn`t have these lines LOL.

Yes it is strange that they are so different.

*is confused*

Yeah, I dunno what to make of how different they are. I've never listened to the isolated lines, have you guys?

I listened to one last night, I think it was the one where rvt says he hears "tell him your his mother" or something like that - I didn't even hear any speaking at all. I dunno if my headphones were being wonky or what, but yeah.

I have never listened to them before, but I tried now - I couldn`t hear any whispers or talking at all. Just static or something LOL.

Yup, same LOL.

I played it like 5 times and was like "where are the words?!" LOL.

I had listened to Penyours (?) ones yesterday at the Fuselage. There were 2 lines I could hear and agree with what she posted, I couldn't even make out words for the rest.

I haven't tried listening to rtv's yet.

I never listen to them  -- I just trust that we are receiving the truth from those two fine techies

I was reading Vozzek69's weekly blog over at DarkUfo (his is my favorite one there) and this part was relevant to the whispers and something I hadn't thought of or heard before as a theory:

Quote :

It Rains A Lot Last thing I noticed: Two of Charlie's flashbacks contained the same grey, pouring-down rain that we see on the island during special occasions. The rain on the island usually precedes some sort of impending doom, but it also comes with one thing - the whispers. I think by now most of us can agree that the whispers do NOT belong to the Others. Too many strange things have been said, forwards and backwards, in too many different ways. I think the rain has to do with whomever is "watching" over the 815'ers, and I think when it rains it sort of opens a window into LOST's world for them. The rain is a conduit, evidenced by the way it enabled Walt to appear to Shannon. Now I've been to London a few times, and I know it rains there... a LOT. That alone might logically explain it always pouring on Charlie. Still, I think this is a special rain. Gut feeling. Which would mean that either the flashbacks are being messed with or someone's been watching over Charlie even before he reached the island.

The last sentence really struck me. What about you guys?

Intersting, but it wasn't raining when  young Ben heard the whispers.

I don't agree with the rain thing... honestly, I think it's kind of ridiculous. Because it rained on the island and in London during Charlie's flashbacks that means that he was being watched, or the flashbacks are incorrect?

Um, it rains everywhere.

Yeah it does rain everywhere LOL.
I thought it was interesting to think of the concept that the island may have "visited" the Losties pre-crash. However, a lot of that thought process is now a bit out the window in light of Lost: The Answers.

From last week:
(as per Lostpedia)

LEFT
"You have to believe it's me, Nikki"
"Shush"
"Did anyone say something?"
"I said nothing"
"You better not say a f**king thing or talk about Desmond"
"It's Me"

RIGHT
I'm not going to listen to them"
"It's January 7th"
"I see somebody"
"Do you recognize him?"  

--Last edited by ILovedEko on 2008-02-08 02:22:46 --

Thanks ILE!   I love reading the whispers, they are kinda creepy!!